Poverty Pushes Abortion. Military Spending Pushes Poverty.

Posted on November 17, 2026 By

by Sarah Terzo

​Emily Berning, co-founder and president of the pro-life group Let Them Live, sent a September 22, 2026 email about Lucia, who came to them for help after scheduling an abortion.

Pregnant for the second time, Lucia abruptly lost her job. Her partner needed to travel out of state to care for a sick relative, leaving her without his income as well.

Berning wrote:

[T]he joy of Lucia’s pregnancy quickly turned to fear. Feeling trapped, she scheduled an abortion…

This is what happens so often with the moms who reach out to us. They desperately want to keep their babies but financial problems make abortion feel like their only option.

Let Them Live took up a collection for Lucia – enough to pay her rent, groceries, and other living expenses temporarily. With the financial burden lifted, Berning said, Lucia “could finally look toward the future with hope.”

She canceled her abortion appointment.

Berning shared Lucia’s ultrasound photo with the caption “[T]his is what happens when financial barriers are removed.”

Emily Berning (@emilyberningofficial) • FacebookEmily Berning

Financial Problems Push Abortions

Financial problems are a common reason why people choose abortion. In one survey of women having abortions, 73% gave finances as a reason. For one in five, it was the main or only reason.

Laura Hussey surveyed post-abortive women on why they aborted. There were 13 options, two of which dealt with financial needs. Of all the options, these two were the least likely to be marked as unimportant or inapplicable.[i]

Women living in poverty are overrepresented among those having abortions. Only 16% of American women of childbearing age live below the poverty line, but they received roughly half (49%) of all abortions in 2014. An additional 26% of abortions were among those with incomes 100% to 199% of the poverty line; yet they make up 18% of women.

As demographer Diana Greene Foster said in the New York Times, “The patient population in abortion clinics is increasingly made up of poor women.”

Hussey also surveyed women who came to pregnancy resource centers considering abortion but chose to have their babies. She asked them what factors were important in convincing them to choose life. Two of the options were:

“I got help affording a baby from a government program like welfare (TANF), food stamps, Medicaid, childcare assistance, or housing assistance”

and

“I got help affording a baby from family, friends, my employer, school, or church or another organization.”

Nearly half (49%) said government assistance was “very important” to their decision, and 59% said nongovernmental assistance was “very important.”[ii]

raising minimum wage

Currently, there is little financial support available for single mothers, pregnant women, and poor families, and recent cuts have made things much worse.

In the United States, Temporary Aid for Needy Families is the modern name for what was called welfare. It is available to single mothers and poor families. The average amount received by a family of three is $552 a month – and only 21% of poor families receive anything at all. A family has little chance of surviving on this amount.

In the US, the average two-bedroom apartment costs $1933, and a one-bedroom averages $1667. A family relying on “welfare,” then, would be homeless. There isn’t any state where $552 could pay for a one-bedroom apartment – much less one with a separate bedroom for a child or children.

The SNAP program, formerly known as food stamps, helps poor families afford groceries. In 2025, the average SNAP benefit per individual was only $187 a month. Since then, Republicans have enacted the largest cut to SNAP in history. Even before the cuts, many families struggled to afford food. In 2025, over half of Virginia families couldn’t afford to feed their children.

Since then, over five million people have lost access to SNAP, and that number is expected to grow considerably over the next year. In some states, 46% of SNAP recipients have lost their benefits. In just 28 states, 3.6 million were cut from the program. Shockingly, half were children – 51% – leaving over 1.5 million children without the assistance they relied on. The total number of children who lost benefits may be higher than 2 million – so far.

At the same time, there has been no increase in employment numbers. The families that have lost SNAP haven’t replaced those losses through working.

This isn’t surprising – 86% of SNAP recipients are children, disabled adults, or elderly retired persons who cannot work. Only 14% are able-bodied people of working age, and most are already working full time.

Does Government Assistance Help?

But does the presence or absence of government assistance really affect abortion rates? Another survey from Hussey presents an answer.

Hussey asked women who had abortions:

Other countries provide a lot of assistance to women and their families that the government, employers, and schools in the US do not provide. These countries give women things like free childcare, free healthcare, money they can use to pay their family’s expenses, and the chance to take months or even years off of work with pay after giving birth.

Would you have made a different decision about your pregnancy if you could get that kind of help?

Laura Hussey

Only 44% said they still would’ve chosen abortion if our country had more generous programs. Twenty-two percent said they definitely would have had their babies. The rest were unsure.[iii]

If the women in this survey are representative of all those having abortions, a more robust social safety net would save 246,600 babies a year – at minimum – and possibly more. And this would be something that would get little to no pushback from the pro-choice movement.

If we could get Republican, ostensibly pro-life, politicians to reverse course and expand anti-poverty programs instead of cutting them, we could save many more preborn lives that we have (at least so far) by overturning Roe. Since Dobbs, the number of abortions has gone up, not down – although the reasons for this are complicated, and Dobbs may still have prevented some abortions.

New Jersey instituted a family cap to TANF payments in 1990. Until then, a woman receiving government assistance received more money after a birth to help support the baby. This benefit was eliminated for some women.

The abortion rate in New Jersey had been declining since 1985 – but after the family cap went into effect, this trend “reversed dramatically.” In one year, the abortion rate among poor people rose by 10% and then began “a steady trajectory upward.”[iv]

Studies confirmed a link between the new law and increased abortion rates. One found that abortions among those affected by the policy change were 14% higher than those unaffected[v]; another found a 32% increase in abortions among Black women.[vi]

See more here.

Great Britain saw abortions increase after it enacted a new two-child tax credit limit. Abortion rates rose 4% that year, and 57% of women subject to the change gave it as their reason for having an abortion.

For example:

If there was no two-child limit, I would have kept the baby, but I couldn’t afford to feed and clothe it … I’ve really struggled to come to terms with my decision.

For more information, see here.

Many single mothers and poor families struggle to afford childcare. A full-time job at minimum wage pays roughly $15,080 a year. Yet childcare for an infant ranges from $7461 to $15,417 a year and for pre-school age $6239 to $11,050. Many single mothers can’t afford childcare. They can’t work without leaving their preschool-age child/children to fend for themselves.

Even if they could afford to pay, 51% of children live in “childcare deserts,” where there are no options for child care at all.

This forces single mothers out of the workplace, even if they are physically capable of working and willing to do so, leaving them at the mercy of an inadequate system.

Subsidies for childcare, then, would be a powerful tool to fight poverty – enabling poor families to support themselves rather than relying on the government.

But while speaking at an Easter luncheon, President Trump said:

It’s not possible for us to take care of day care, Medicaid, Medicare, all these individual things…You can’t do it… We have to take care of one thing: military protection. We have to guard the country.

The YouTube video containing these remarks posted by the White House was later deleted, but not before news outlets covered the speech.

Military Spending

The US spends massive amounts of money on the military – far more than any other country. In 2025, US military spending was $954 billion. Russia, Germany, Ukraine, India, and the UK combined spent $905 billion. The US spent more money on weapons and military infrastructure than the next five countries combined.

Newsweek found that in just one month (September 2025), the Department of Defense under Pete Hegseth splurged on gourmet food for military leaders, including $2 million on Alaskan King crab, $6.9 million on lobster tail, and $15.1 million on rib-eye steak. Hegseth also spent nearly $100,000 on a grand piano, a gift for an Air Force Chief of Staff.

The most severely disabled veterans, those rated at 100% disability, including quadriplegics and multiple amputees, receive about $4000 a month in compensation. Therefore, the amount spent on that grand piano equaled the monthly income of 25 severely disabled veterans.

Disabled vets rated at 50% get about $1300; those rated 10% get $100.40. Payments to disabled veterans total $12.45 billion per month – a mere 16% of the military budget.

In comparison, the first six days of the war with Iran cost $11.3 billion. As of July 23, 2026, the US had spent $37.5 billion on that war. Trump requested $1.5 trillion for the 2027 military budget, with $71.4 billion going directly to nuclear weapons.

If only a small portion of military spending were given to poverty-prevention programs instead, we would have more than enough money to fund them. Our tax dollars could be used to support life, not death. This would be far more rewarding.

As Emily Berning says, “[T]he joy of hearing that another mom has chosen life never fades.”

 

[i] Laura Selena Hussey, The Pro-Life Pregnancy Help Movement: Serving Women or Saving Babies? (Lawrence, Kansas: University Press of Kansas, 2020) 207–208.

[ii] Ibid., 204–205, 206.

[iii] Ibid., 206-207.

[iv] Michael J. Camasso, Family Caps, Abortion and Women of Color: Research Connection and Political Rejection (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007) 28.

[v] Ibid., 105.

[vi] “Study Finds New Welfare Policy Boosted NJ’s Abortion Rate,” Boston Globe, June 18, 1998, p. 18.

 

Get our SHORT Biweekly e-Newsletter



Email & Social Media Marketing by VerticalResponse

abortion • military • poverty


Thoughts on the 2026 U.S. Mid-Terms

Posted on November 10, 2026 By

by Rachel MacNair

First, good news: Idaho turned down a petition-driven effort to overturn their abortion ban. Colorado turned down a petition-driven effort to require local police to turn over arrestees to ICE, which could have been devastating for pregnant women, unborn children, war refugees, etc. Massachusetts turned down a petition-driven veto referendum, so gun safety laws the legislature passed remain; we were interested in preventing mass shootings, a form of mini-war.

As for candidates – over the decades, they go back and forth on which party predominates. We have to work with what we have. At the grassroots, we always have.

Learn a Lesson: Missouri

I vote in Missouri, so I watched Amendment 3 develop. It was to overturn the Amendment 3 of 2024, which made abortion a state constitutional right. It passed with only 52%. Since the original’s advertising kept saying Missouri’s abortion ban went too far, many didn’t understand how extreme the 2024 amendment was in the other direction.

So it was reasonable to think with a little tweaking, the normal adding of the rape and incest exception, perhaps getting it on the ballot could get this repealed.

Unfortunately, they took a page from the pro-abortion playbook with a “ballot candy” technique. They added a provision they thought would be popular and get it over the finish line: banning transgender surgeries for minors.

This does something against Missouri law – having two topics in one measure. But a court decided they were the same topic: reproductive medicine. That looks ridiculous to me. Neither has anything to do with actual reproduction. I suppose the judge was thinking of medicine involving private body parts. This is a common problem in the abortion debate.

Early on, the court also changed the ballot language to be more accurate. I was relieved, since being put in a position of being expected to defend deliberately deceptive language was a position I didn’t want to be in. The best I could do is to say that the original pro-abortion amendment had also used deceptive language. That’s not much of a defense.

Then I watched the ads. The pro-3 group offered an ad advocating how important the ban on transgender surgery for minors was, as if that were what the measure was about. That made it simple for the anti-3 side: they just pointed out such surgery was already illegal in Missouri, so saying this was what it was about was a trick. This measure was really about an abortion ban. I watched painfully a surreal scene: the pro-abortion side was actually being more accurate.

Then abortion advocates did the onslaught of ads with predictable content. I could easily have refuted what they said, but of course I don’t have that kind of money. The people who did let them get away with it, unrefuted.

They not only lost with only 45% of the vote, but they spent so much work only to show slippage of support for the pro-life cause. Given all the people who stayed home in this political environment, there may not have been much help for it.

But they didn’t even use this as a public education opportunity, so that even if we lost the election in the short term, we still could have gained a more educated public for the long term.

Friends, please learn these lessons:

1) Abortion advocates may have money and know how to win politically, but that doesn’t make them good role models.

because

2) Deception in service of a goal of promoting violence can be efficient, but deception with an eye to preventing violence just doesn’t work so well.

Character matters.

Democrats Take Over Congress

Being ever the person looking for signs of hope, I offer:

A common perception was that a major issue was the war in Iran. Even those who don’t oppose war for the reason we do – namely, it kills people – think it shouldn’t happen just because one man says so. Especially a man who promised as a candidate he wouldn’t do that kind of thing. But some speculated the “wag-the-dog” scenario of using a war to distract from a sex scandal, namely the Epstein files, was the actual motivation here. Whether or not this is so, the tactic has probably lost its potency. Perhaps in the future this especially despicable reason for going to war has lost its ability to be a temptation.

I think a case can be made that repudiation of Trump is better for the pro-life movement. He’s a lip-service pro-lifer, but functionally pro-abortion. Single-issue voters point out he wasn’t nearly as bad as Clinton or Harris would have been on abortion, and of course appointing the judges that finally overturned Roe v. Wade is a major achievement. But it’s now achieved. Now some conservatives make the case that Trump is sabotaging the pro-life movement. Positive actions to help on abortion-prevention public policy are things the Republicans mainly didn’t do in the past two years when they had the chance (or in the case of Planned Parenthood defunding, they allowed it to lapse). There’s no reason to think they would have done better had they remained in control.

A prime illustration: the Talarico-Paxton Senate race in Texas. From a cold-hearted paperwork point of view, Paxton as state attorney general took action on some good abortion policy in Texas. But his corruption was so bad, it turned off many who always vote Republican but couldn’t stomach voting for him. He would vote against abortion when bills come up, but it would give a stench hard to recuperate from.

Talarico, on the other hand, can pretty well be counted on to vote the wrong way on abortion.  But in a respectful conversation with a pro-lifer, when he claimed the Bible was silent on abortion, she pointed out the Ten Commandments say “thou shalt not kill.” The pro-lifers I saw commenting on this were disgusted with his approach, of course. But the point is, he was listening to her and being respectful.

I have a sense that if he could ever give me just 15 minutes to explain out the problems, he’d actually listen.  And he’s among the kind of people who would find the consistent-life approach more persuasive than some other arguments that could be made to him.

So he’s not a fanatic. Being a non-fanatic that can listen is an awfully low bar, but it’s better than a whole lot of Democrats do. So I’m ever hopeful.

Lobbying

The positive is that we may get better funding back to social services and health care, which in addition to their poverty-prevention aspects help pregnant women choose life, and help targets of “aid in dying” to avoid the practice. Some of the states may become better on the death penalty; the governor of California commuted all death sentences, a quarter of death row in the United States, just after the election.

One major negative, of course, is that abortion policy could deteriorate badly.

The grassroots parts of the pro-life movement remain as strong as ever, and if Democrats over-reach, as is the custom of politicians, some more people may get angry enough to be active.

But I do feel for the lobbying arm of the movement. Prospects seem to be to spend time keeping bad things from happening rather than promoting good things to happen. This is exacerbated by how all the work pro-lifers had put into getting better policy outcomes was mainly being ignored by officeholders who claimed to be with us.

But here we are on federal legislation:

  • Nationally “codifying Roe,” reinstating the nation-wide ban on abortion-regulating or banning legislation. Democrats have in the past discussed getting rid of the filibuster to do it. It may happen, but I haven’t seen it discussed in the mainstream punditry after the election. There’s discussion about how much Democrats want to try to actually pass things that can get enough Republicans to be veto-proof, or to avoid vetoes.
  • Since the Hyde Amendment has been a rider every year and Republicans did nothing to make it more permanent when they had the chance, there’s a very real danger here. See our post on how Hyde helps low-income women.
  • The one-year defunding of Planned Parenthood ending last July never got renewed, and it certainly won’t for the time being.

Rachel MacNair at literature table

But again, we have grassroots. The Consistent Life Network has a project website called Grassroots Defunding: Finding Alternatives to Planned Parenthood. This isn’t merely getting women away from abortions, which the pro-life movement does well, but getting women at Planned Parenthood for other things away from the institution. We have community health centers nearby each individual Planned Parenthood center listed, plus other resources.

Also, the Problems at Planned Parenthood Committee runs a facts-based documentation website on Problems at Planned Parenthood, designed especially for people who refer or donate to Planned Parenthood, along with journalists and other researchers.

===============

See also:

Scandals with Mirror Images

What History Shows: The Consistent Life Ethic Works for Pro-life Referendums

How Consistent-life Advocacy Would Benefit from Ranked-Choice Voting

 

Get our SHORT Biweekly e-Newsletter



Email & Social Media Marketing by VerticalResponse

elections


“A Chain Reaction of Spiritual Atoms”: Buddhist Opposition to Nuclear Weapons

Posted on November 3, 2026 By

Part 1 in a series on opposition to nuclear weapons within different religions.

by John Whitehead

Hatred will not cease by hatred, but by love alone.
This is the ancient law.
All fear violence, all are afraid of death.
Seeing the similarity to oneself,
one should not use violence or have it used.

— Dhammapada 1:5-6

Buddhism and the history of nuclear weapons overlap in different ways. Two countries that possess nuclear weapons—China and North Korea—have historically had large Buddhist populations, although in both countries the governments that built the weapons have been anti-religious. Another country with a significant Buddhist tradition, Japan, is the only country ever to be the target of nuclear weapons in wartime.

Buddhist tradition offers grounds for rejecting nuclear weapons and their use. A central Buddhist precept exhorts people to reject violence and to love all. Inner disposition is especially important. Rejecting hatred and divisive attitudes in favor of loving-kindness and an appreciation of all beings’ interdependence is a basic Buddhist value.

Since nuclear weapons’ invention, Buddhists have been among those seeking to prevent these weapons’ use or calling for their abolition.

Resolving a Nuclear Crisis

U Thant, 1963

A major Buddhist statesman who worked against the nuclear threat was U Thant, the Burmese diplomat who served as Secretary-General of the United Nations from 1961 to 1971.

Thant began his days with meditation, to cultivate “a certain feeling of detachment…to separate oneself from the conflicts outside.” He described meditation as “an exercise in suppressing evil thoughts and evil attitudes—anger, bitterness, malice, hatred.” (Quoted in “The Meditation of U Thant, New York Times, December 13, 1964) He spoke out against violence, which “erodes the spirit of law, order and international morality.”

Thant’s commitment to avoiding violence was put to a spectacular test during the Cuban Missile Crisis of October 1962, when the United States and Soviet Union approached the brink of nuclear war. The secretary-general played an important role in defusing the potential nuclear confrontation.

When news of Soviet nuclear missiles being stationed in Cuba became public on October 22, the United States announced a naval blockade of Cuba. Fearing a US-Soviet military confrontation, on October 24, Thant appealed to the United States to suspend the blockade and the Soviet Union to suspend any shipments of weapons to Cuba. He also proposed a settlement where the Soviets would withdraw the missiles if the United States pledged not to invade Cuba.

In subsequent negotiations, the two sides reached an agreement consistent with Thant’s proposal. During these negotiations, Thant served as mediator, offering advice to and serving as a go-between among the different parties in pursuit of a final deal. Later, Thant and the United Nations helped facilitate US-Soviet-Cuban negotiations over the details of withdrawing weapons from Cuba.

Following the crisis’ resolution, US President John F. Kennedy commented, “U Thant has put the world deeply in his debt.”

After the crisis, Thant continued to speak out against the nuclear threat. He described testing nuclear weapons as “a manifestation of a very dangerous psychosis.”

Responding to an American politician’s suggestion that nuclear weapons be used in the United States’ war in Vietnam, Thant declared, “I am against the use of atomic weapons for destructive purposes anywhere, under any circumstances—and anybody who proposes the use of atomic weapons for destructive purposes is, in my view, out of his mind.”

Advocating for Nuclear Abolition

Other prominent Buddhist figures have spoken out against nuclear weapons. The Vietnamese monk and peace activist Thich Nhat Hanh wrote:

The nuclear arms race is inextricably linked to other forms of violence and suffering that afflict life on Earth. Recognizing this, I propose reductions in military spending with corresponding allocations to be used for the alleviation of world hunger  . . .

I hope the United States will independently declare a stop to the arms race and invite Russia, China, and all other arms-producing countries to do the same…Then, if other countries do reciprocate, the US could take another step toward complete and general disarmament.” (“From Weapons to Human Solidarity,” 1971)

Thich Nhat Hanh

Significant Buddhist anti-nuclear advocacy also has unsurprisingly come from Japan.

Ichiro Moritaki was an academic and Zen Buddhist who survived the Hiroshima bombing, although he was blinded in one eye. During his recovery, meditation led him to a determination that humanity must turn away from the pursuit of power toward the practice of love. Proclaiming that “Nuclear weapons and humanity cannot coexist,” Moritaki dedicated himself to anti-nuclear work, founding the Nobel Peace Prize-winning survivor organization Nihon Hidankyo.

In 1962, Moritaki began a practice of sit-ins at Hiroshima to protest nuclear tests. Commenting on the protests, which grew in size, Moritaki wrote, “There is no other path for a peace movement than that of appealing to public opinion without having recourse to any violent action.” He described the sit-ins as “a universal mode of nonviolent demonstration in which young and old in both West and East can participate.” Moritaki found inspiration in how protesting the nuclear threat prompted people to go beyond concern for their own affairs and to act selflessly.

A major Buddhist organization involved in anti-nuclear activism is Soka Gakkai International (SGI). Founded in Japan in 1930, Soka Gakkai grew out of Nichiren Buddhism, a tradition that has emphasized people’s equality and challenging those in power. Under its third president, Daisaku Ikeda, Soka Gakkai grew into an international association of over 10 million people in 192 countries.

Ikeda spoke out on social justice and peace, particularly nuclear abolition. In 2009, he appealed to the world’s nations, civil society organizations, and the United Nations to join in a common abolition effort. In his appeal, Ikeda commented,

If we are to put the era of nuclear terror behind us, we must struggle against the real “enemy.” That enemy is not nuclear weapons per se, nor is it the states that possess or develop them. The real enemy that we must confront is the ways of thinking that justify nuclear weapons; the readiness to annihilate others when they are seen as a threat or as a hindrance to the realization of our objectives…

Raising one’s voice or taking action is something we all can do. All that is required are the natural feelings shared by people everywhere: the desire to live in peace, the wish to protect those we love, the determination to spare the world’s children needless suffering.

SGI has long worked closely with the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN), collaborating on peace education efforts. These efforts have included documenting the stories of atomic bomb survivors and releasing a video on the nuclear threat, “Reshape History.” ICAN Executive Director Beatrice Fihn commented, “SGI has been one of our greatest partners in this fight.”

Danny Hall, the Lead Capitol Hill Representative & Faith Community Outreach Coordinator for the Back from the Brink campaign continues the SGI tradition. A Buddhist, Hall was inspired by Daisaku Ikeda’s writings to dedicate himself to nuclear abolition.

“Nuclear abolition is not just a cause,” Hall wrote, “it is a force that gives meaning to our lives, ensuring that all other pursuits for good can thrive without the shadow of nuclear threats.” Hall’s activism includes building support for the Back from the Brink resolutions in the US Congress (H.Res 317/S.Res 323).

Hall organized this year’s “Nuclear Prayer Day” in Washington, DC, on August 6, the anniversary of the Hiroshima bombing. The Prayer Day was an occasion for faith leaders and activists to pray and advocate for an end to the nuclear threat and for reallocating resources from weapons to helping life to flourish. Held in the United Methodist Building on Capitol Hill, the event was illuminated by paper lanterns decorated by children in Hiroshima and Washington, DC. One speaker commented, “Each lantern symbolizes remembrance, hope, peace, and global solidarity.”

Buddhism guides Hall’s work through its recognition of the dignity (or “Buddha nature”) of every human, the “common human thread that exists among all the different kinds of people.” Despite propaganda that may portray someone as a hated “other,” Buddhism teaches “this person’s life has value, this person has something valuable to contribute to the world.”

Hall’s faith provides hope. “We’re capable of more than we think we are,” he says. “Faith becomes very real in people’s lives when you’re really confronted with situations that stretch you as a human being.” Hall says, “I feel grateful to do this work.” (Interview, July 7, 2026)

A Crucial Role for Peace

Buddhists have long played a crucial role in working against nuclear weapons, and their faith can continue to inspire efforts to free humanity from the nuclear threat. Ichiro Moritaki, who emerged from the horror of Hiroshima to advocate for peace, summed up this mission in verse:

A chain reaction of spiritual atoms
Must overcome
The chain reaction of material atoms.

If you’re part of a faith group interested in getting involved with Back from the Brink, you can reach out to Danny Hall at danny@preventnuclearwar.org.

===================================

For more of our posts relating religion to nuclear weapons, see: 

Nukes and the Pro-Life Christian: A Conservative Takes a Second Look at the Morality of Nuclear Weapons / Karen Swallow Prior

One Catholic Case Against Nuclear Deterrence

Get our SHORT Biweekly e-Newsletter



Email & Social Media Marketing by VerticalResponse

nuclear weapons • Religion


The Rehumanize International Conference 2026

Posted on October 27, 2026 By

The conference started out with a dinner honoring long-time consistent lifer and pro-life feminist Carol Crossed, seen here at the microphone:

Carol has served on our Board of Directors and for a time was our Executive Director; she’s still on our Advisory Board and quite active with us.

==================

Here we offer some thoughts from attendees from our Board:

Sarah Terzo

I learned a lot at the conference. When listening to Julia Smucker’s talk, I was struck by how complicated the US immigration system is. It made me wonder why there couldn’t be an easier path to citizenship. I felt I came away with a better understanding of the nuances of the immigration debate.

Beth Fox and Miles Gloetzner had compelling things to say about end-of-life care. Beth talked about the red tape that made it so difficult for her to access hospice. She says that when one place got her application they threw it out after seeing that her age was listed as 34 because they thought it was an error. Her age made it difficult for her to access the services she needed.

Miles revealed that Medicare caps hospice benefits at $33,000, meaning that if people enter hospice too soon and don’t die within a certain amount of time, they can max out their benefits and be kicked out of hospice, ending up much worse off than before. This is a political decision someone made to balance the budget, and it’s a serious problem that a lot of people don’t realize they may run into at the end of their lives. As Miles noted, dying in this country is very expensive.

Beth also spoke about the ableism people display when they assume disabled people have a poor quality of life. When she needed to be on a respirator, several doctors tried to dissuade her, telling her she should choose death instead. Beth remarked that had she listened to her doctors, she would have missed out on so much. Beth also revealed that people have said to her that if they were in her position, they would kill themselves. I had someone say something like that to me. (I am also a disabled wheelchair user.) I don’t know how anyone can possibly think that is ok.

Richard Stith

Eric Scheidler’s talk asked Rehumanize and its friends to keep being bridges, presumably from pro-life to liberals and the left. But I was also struck by the fact that his presence at the Rehumanize conference was a bridge from us to mainstream, traditional pro-lifers.

Our seamless-garment approach is often viewed with suspicion by strongly anti-abortion folks. They mistakenly think we might not be absolutely opposed to abortion, if we also oppose other violations of human dignity. But Joe and Ann Scheidler, and their son Eric, are universally known to be solidly against abortion. So I think having him join us helps overcome that wrongful suspicion by our fellow anti-abortion activists.

I was also impressed by the gentle tone and content of his talk. He has clearly put his heart and soul and mind into the task of building a society where all children, and their moms and dads, are welcomed, protected, and supported.

Rachel MacNair

I was pleased with how rich and insightful all the presentations were. I presented on the upcoming peace-and-life referendums with a good audience with thoughtful questions. Also, as Richard says above, I was pleased that Eric Scheidler gave such a fine presentation and that the  room was crowded, so there’s good networking going on there.

One of the points Eric made was that there are two approaches to ending abortion that must go together. If we only make it illegal, then desperate women will travel or otherwise get abortions surreptitiously. Obviously, those stuck in poverty or near poverty need material help and social services as well. On the other hand, merely offering the social services might lower the abortion rate but doesn’t do the job by itself – Scandinavian countries have admirable social services but still plenty of abortions. I would add that plenty of middle-class and upper-class women who have no material obstacles to childrearing are also still getting plenty of abortions. As Eric points out elsewhere, illegalization in a few states hasn’t meant widespread prosecution; it’s meant that abortion facilities have shut down. So people do need to have an understanding that it’s legally out of the question, and that will make them more likely to seek out the social services.

This reminded me of a recent article in The New York Times: We Know How to Fix Homelessness. Look at Denver. Homeless encampments may be seen as a problem to people encountering them, but simply breaking them up and sending people away with no place to go is just plain cruel. Offering the needed social services helps, but doesn’t do enough when they can be ignored. In any event, we need to experiment and see what works best, not merely assert what we think would work best.

And we’re certainly in an all-hands-on-deck situation. 

Rachel’s talk at RI conference.

Christine Yao Pelliccioni

 Sometimes things don’t go as expected. I had brought toys, books, and snacks to occupy my nearly two-year-old for the hour I was speaking. I had brought my father-in-law along to chase her around, and her stroller so they could go outside. But none of this would do- in this big crowd of new people (we had not stayed at the conference for long on Saturday since her brother had gotten an ear infection, but that’s another story), she needed Mama to hold her. Which I did throughout most of my portion of the talk, until she decided she was bored and wanted to jump out of my arms. She stood at my feet for a while, fascinated by the microphone. When she started trying to grab the microphone, I signaled to my father-in-law it really was time to get little miss outside. She did not go happily, but she went.

I don’t know if those attending my talk could see me cringe as my toddler wailed. Thankfully, executive director of Rehumanize (and mom of 6) Lauren Pope was able to console my Maggie. I am so grateful that I was speaking to such an authentically pro-life crowd, where no one batted an eye at my little one causing quite the ruckus. I am so grateful Lauren went out of her way to help a fellow mom and pro-life advocate in the most genuine way. I hope someday I can return the favor and continue building a wonderful culture of life.

Christy’s talk at RI conference

=======================================================

 

For reports on previous Rehumanize conferences, see: 

conferences


Revisiting Abortion Advocate Predictions Regarding Miscarriage Care

Posted on October 20, 2026 By

Abernathy and baby

Abernathy and baby

by Jacqueline Harvey Abernathy, Ph.D.

October is Pregnancy and Infant Loss Awareness Month. As a mother of eight, only two of whom survived to birth, I am well aware of how devastating losing a baby is, especially  since I’ve dedicated myself for decades to pass laws that protect all pre-born children from dying from abortion violence.

 

In all those years of activism, I never imagined that the 2021 reversal of Roe v. Wade would result in abortion advocates weaponizing my deceased children to wish me harm for my part in passing laws that protect women and children alike.

Since the Dobbs decision, I have repeatedly been told by people how they wish more of my babies would die naturally in miscarriage and maybe even die myself from unnecessarily delayed medical care that they blame squarely on the laws I helped pass and uphold in court as an expert witness against the abortion industry.

Reacting to the Reversal of Roe

and Subsequent Attacks on Mourning Mothers

Although I supported and helped implement the reversal of Roe v. Wade, I never truly believed it would prevail or that, once it did, my miscarriages and those of fellow moms in mourning would be wielded against  in protest of losing legal abortion access nationwide.

Over my many decades in the movement, I’ve seen through a disheartening host of supposedly benevolent rationales for legal feticide. They color abortion violence as merciful toward women in crisis, children with disabilities, and so on. The reversal of Roe v. Wade  inspired a similar campaign that focused instead on women like me, who’ve lost children by chance but for the express purpose of championing killing children by choice.

I immediately observed a swathe of disingenuous and misleading headlines by those who support killing children no different or less precious than the sons and daughters I have buried over the years. They use other moms in mourning the same deceitful way, attempting to elicit sympathy by feigning empathy for our anguish without actually caring at all about us or out children.

Misrepresenting Miscarriage Care as Equivalent to Elective Abortion

All of these supposed concerns for mourning mothers didn’t come from anyone except those who advocate elective abortion. They all claimed to be deeply concerned about my health and safety should I face another loss, since miscarriage management can involve the same drugs and surgical interventions to deliver a deceased child or evacuate retained tissue.

I’m unfortunately well-acquainted with these treatments because I have needed medical intervention in most of my losses. I’ve experienced an ectopic pregnancy, two chemical pregnancies and three missed miscarriages, one where I needed emergency care after laboring at home failed to deliver the baby.

There was another where I had to induce labor with misoprostol because my use of progesterone to hopefully prevent another loss was unnaturally preventing my body from recognizing that I had already lost my child a few weeks earlier.

I’ve also undergone a dilation and curettage (D&C) after losing my seventh child. This ironically took place at a Catholic hospital under the care of my Catholic OB/GYN on the anniversary of Roe v. Wade the year before it finally fell.

The demagogues insisted that laws protecting children from intentional, violent destruction with these drugs and procedures might make legitimate, therapeutic access to treatment more cumbersome.

I was strongly warned that the Dobbs decision would assuredly interfere with this type of necessary, emergency treatment that I needed to heal. The subtext: they’ve banned abortions, so labor-inducing drugs and uterine evacuation surgeries won’t exist for women when they need them. As if women who need legitimate medical care to manage a pregnancy loss must go to abortion clinics for treatment instead of the hospital or their OB/GYN. We do not. We never have.

Manipulating Medical Language

to Conflate Killing With Legitimate Life-Saving Treatment

The claim went beyond how miscarriage care and abortion are similar into a pervasive misinformation campaign. Abortion advocates mischaracterize the commonplace care women receive for pregnancy loss as functionally no different than abortion violence.

This myth is based in easily manipulated medical terminology. The abrupt end of a pregnancy is abortion, either one that happens naturally where the child’s tragic death can’t be prevented (a spontaneous abortion), or one that’s chosen that deliberately kills a child who would most likely survive if simply left alone (an induced abortion). The former we informally call miscarriage while the latter truly is an abortion.

Calling both abortion without a description equates the unavoidable loss of a wanted child who died of natural causes with purposely killing an unwanted child using chemicals or a curette. They drop the critical modifier “spontaneous” or “induced” and just call everything an abortion and present miscarriage and killing as technically the same.

Broad use of the word “abortion” without that distinction conveniently equates the intentional ending of a pregnancy by lethal violence with the unintentional ending of a pregnancy from uninduced fetal demise to make a child dying by chance comparable to a child dying by choice.

This is like saying that losing a spouse to anaphylaxis from an unknown nut allergy is the same as hiding their Epi-pen before force-feeding them a PB & J. A murderous spouse doesn’t inspire the same level of sympathy as a grieving widow. Nor does the deliberate killing of a child compare to mournfully laying them to rest.

Therefore, my greatest pain becomes a prime opportunity to assert that abortion bans are not just about women who got pregnant but don’t want their babies so they say abortion bans are dangerous for poor, heartbroken mothers like me who wanted their babies more than anything and will physically and emotionally suffer if we don’t allow abortions for everyone.

Ill-Wishes for Pro-Life Women Have Turned Into

Self-Fulfilling Prophecies Harming All Women

I’ve watched the hypothetical fear-mongering about potential future pregnancy loss used against mourning mothers turn into real-world exploitation of actual women and their very real, very missed deceased children. I was incensed at so many abortion advocates feigning concern for mothers like me, women who mourn our children we couldn’t save despite our utmost efforts.

They use our misfortune as a manipulation tactic. We know it is insincere, since there are never calls to reform the laws to protect mothers suffering from miscarriage but only calls to repeal abortion laws completely as the supposed only means to that end. Until that end is achieved, taking advantage of grieving mothers to advance their agenda is clearly more important to them than we are.

If any abortion policies I helped lobby into law have unintentionally harmed women suffering the pain of miscarriage (a pain I know all too well), I would be the first person calling for reform. Not just to protect these women but also to protect myself. But the bottom line is there is nothing in state abortion laws that preclude the medical removal of a deceased child.

There is nothing to reform and frankly, any lies that can be fabricated from miscarriage victims into propaganda to repeal abortion laws is far more useful to their agenda.

There are catastrophic stories where women have suffered and died from delayed miscarriage care that predates the fall of Roe because medical malpractice and neglect have been problems throughout human history. We hear more about these tragedies now because they make good political talking points.

Abortion laws are now blamed opportunistically, when instead the blame belongs squarely on negligent doctors who try to shift their guilt onto the policies, citing ambiguity regarding when they could lawfully intervene.

Efforts to ensure that laws are clear and unobstructive to medical judgment to protect women becomes improbable, though, when there’s an entire movement resolved to vindicate their prediction that abortion bans will jeopardize actual medical care for women. Attempts to blame abortion laws overshadow valid concerns that absolutely do need to be addressed in order to be alleviated rather than propped up as political talking points.

There is no reason, medical or otherwise, for the denial of life-saving healthcare when a pre-born child is not deceased or nonviable and threatens the life or health of their mother.

If there actually is ambiguity regarding when doctors can save women’s lives in a medical crisis, it is this confusion that needs to change, not laws that save the lives of children when no one has to die. The only people suggesting there is a trade-off are those who want only women protected when senselessly killing their children goes wrong.

The Only Way to Protect Pregnant Women

is to Protect Their Unborn Children

I resent the lie that pits mothers against our own babies as if we were somehow adversaries instead of family. My support of abortion regulations has never been protecting unborn children at the expense of their mothers but to protect babies and mothers alike. It was never either/or. It was always both.

The truth is: protecting unborn children protects their mothers. When laws deem any lives disposable, that is when everyone suffers.

=================================

For more perspectives on miscarriages, see: 

Hospital’s Attitude Adds to Couple’s Heartbreak

Tear Gas and Miscarriages

Threats to the Unborn Beyond Abortion

miscarriage


The Botched Execution of Christa Pike

Posted on October 13, 2026 By

by Christina Yao Pelliccioni

The Christa Pike case has led to many different twists, turns, and inconsistencies. To start with the facts, Christa Pike was sentenced to death after murdering her classmate in 1995. On September 30, she was given two doses of the lethal drug pentobarbital. After she survived, she was taken to the hospital. She regained the ability to walk and is eating. She has also regained some movement in her arms, which were burned and blistered during the execution attempt.

Pike is the only person known to survive a lethal injection. Now she has returned to death row, transported back to the facility where she has lived for the past 30 years.

Pike’s lawyers say she is dealing with an unknown amount of physical and psychological harm “including the terror, pain, and uncertainty of believing she was about to die.” A judge has demanded documentation of Pike’s psychological state before, during, and after the execution. Tennessee’s governor has halted all executions for the rest of the year. It is unclear when executions will be resumed and what this means for Pike.

Not often does a case so clearly show the flaws within the death penalty. Justice should be served, and if Christa Pike is a threat to the safety of others, she should not be allowed to walk free. But how does the continuation of attempting to end her life bring justice or peace to anyone?

One of the most confusing and inconsistent things about this case is how it’s determined how someone dies vs. being treated. Pike was sent to the hospital after she did not die and will presumably continue to receive medical care in prison. But why give her medical care if she deserves to die? Either she has humanity and is deserving of life, or she is something the state can dispose of or keep at its will.

The logic behind this could be that Pike needs to die in the “right” way, but how can the state decide what the “right” way to die is? If a quick and painless death is what is desired, Pike’s ordeal has shown this is not the way.

So what’s the humane way forward? Not having the death penalty at all. It’s a barbaric and antiquated punishment that must be discontinued.

One would hope that this incident would help those in power realize this and want to distance themselves from this horror. Unfortunately, this seems not to be the case, with the Pentagon planning to live stream an execution in December. [Editor’s note: the live-stream portion of the execution was canceled on October 15.]

This is not the way a compassionate, humane society acts. We must stand up against these dark instances. And we must make sure that these just stay instances. We cannot allow this kind of execution violence to go back to being the norm.

Christa Pike 2023

Editor’s Addition:

This case has some pro-life sources making connections to their abortion and euthanasia issues:

The disturbing connections between Tennessee executions and assisted dying
Cassy Cook, Live Action, October 2, 2026

The drugs used in executions are often the same as those used in assisted suicide, and as witnessed by Pike and Carruthers, these deaths are far more grisly than many realize.

Many assume that lethal injection and euthanasia merely cause someone to fall asleep and then die painlessly, but in reality, the drugs cause pulmonary edema. This means the person’s lungs fill with fluid, and he/she drowns in his/her own secretions.

But because the person is given a paralytic first, both in lethal injections and euthanasia, it is therefore impossible to know what pain or suffering the person might be experiencing.

Experiments with assisted suicide and euthanasia have also been excruciating, with one cocktail said to be “burning patients’ mouths and throats, causing some to scream in pain.”

These are not peaceful, humane deaths, whether during execution or euthanasia.

 

Do We Do Death for Sport?
Kathryn Jean Lopez, National Review, October 12, 2026

And I say that knowing full well that what she did at 18 was barbaric . . . After beating and knifing Slemmer to death, Pike kept a piece of her victim’s crushed skull as a souvenir to show off the next morning.

But we are not a people that lowers itself to barbarism. Unless, perhaps, there is an unborn baby involved and an abortion has been requested. Then we will crush skulls, too, and even leave babies to die if the abortion is botched. And yet we don’t treat murderers this way — we have witnesses to the planned execution, and when Tennessee failed, ambulances arrived at the prison, and Pike was given lifesaving treatment. I suppose we do that because it’s harder to look away from a full-grown adult — although when it comes to assisted suicide, we are willing to overlook that, too.

Looking at the Pike experience, the solution should not be firing squads — a more efficient way of doing the killing. The response should be to err on the side of life. Including long before a crime has ever been committed.

Pike was found to be bipolar, among her other mental-health diagnoses. She was raped throughout her childhood, first by her grandmother’s boyfriend. Her first attempted suicide was when she was twelve. Pike was failed by adults in her life over and over again . . .

Get our SHORT Biweekly e-Newsletter



Email & Social Media Marketing by VerticalResponse

death penalty


Referendums for November 3, 2026: Voting Against Violence

Posted on October 6, 2026 By

by Rachel MacNair

November 4, 2026: Results added in green. 

Since 2020, we’ve been running a project website that tracks U.S. state and local referendums dealing with socially-approved killing of human beings (abortion, the death penalty, euthanasia, war), or related structural violence that leads to killing (poverty and discriminatory practices).

Peace and Life Referendums

Abortion is frequently a ballot topic, especially since the Dobbs decision overturning Roe. The death penalty and euthanasia do make occasional appearances, but not much. War is something that looms large in policy but not in state and local referendums — yet there have been some, especially dealing with war memorials, gun policy that isn’t mere regulation but gets into war relationships, and treating police work as if it were military. Racism will include matters of immigration policy, many symbolic actions that impact how people think, and finally abolishing all slavery by removing the exception for prisons. Quite a few different approaches to alleviating poverty pop up.  More details are explained in the Topic Pages.

Presidential years will bring the greatest number, so you’ll see the list was long in 2020 and 2024, and will likely be again in 2028.  Non-presidential but still even-numbered years see not as many but still quite a few, as in 2022 and this year, which we cover now.
.
Markers:
check mark means we think a yes vote would be best for diminishing violence
.
x means we think a no vote is needed since the referendum encourages socially-approved violence

Abortion:

x

Idaho – a successful petition drive put a pro-abortion statute on the ballot to overturn the state’s abortion ban. Successfully defeated. 

check mark    Missouri – the state legislature put on an amendment to the state constitution to overturn the pro-abortion amendment passed in 2024. Unfortunately, defeated.

x    Nevada – they already voted overwhelmingly in 2024 for a pro-abortion constitutional amendment in a state where no abortion bans were ever contemplated. The rules state they have to vote on it twice before it goes into effect. Unfortunately, passed. 


x     Virginia – the state legislature put a pro-abortion amendment on the ballot. Unfortunately, passed.

War:

x     Arizona – turning policework into the war mindset, the measure seeks to define drug trafficking as terrorism and therefore use war tactics to counter it. Unfortunately, passed.
check mark      Massachusetts – a petition drive put a veto referendum about firearm regulations passed by the legislature on the ballot. We focus only on those that relate to preventing mass shootings, as a form of war.
Fortunately, passed.

Poverty:

check mark      Oklahoma – a successful petition drive for a rise in the minimum wage should have put this on the ballot in 2024, but government officials’ shenanigans delayed it until now. Unfortunately, defeated.

Abortion, Poverty, Racism, War:

x      Colorado – one of the very few that connects several of our issues, a successful petition drive wants to overturn state legislation stopping federal overreach and instead have local authorities turn any undocumented immigrants (or those that can’t prove otherwise right away) accused of a violent crime over to ICE. This bypasses the court system that knows how to adjudicate these properly, in favor of an agency that doesn’t even try to.

Thank heavens, defeated.

Get our SHORT Biweekly e-Newsletter



Email & Social Media Marketing by VerticalResponse

elections


Scandals with Mirror Images

Posted on September 30, 2026 By

by Rachel MacNair

A video clip I saw recently offers a point I’ve thought of for a long time. Since it’s Chuck Todd making the point, and he’s a news analyst of long stature, the point has more heft than me just thinking it alone. He says it’s a theory he’s not 100% certain of, but he finds it persuasive. You can find the clip from Holy Post Media: The Scandal That Changed Evangelical Politics Forever.

The scandal was the one that got Bill Clinton impeached, though not removed from office. Todd says it may help explain why evangelicals later embraced Trump. At the time, evangelicals as a whole were keen on the idea that character mattered.

Some feminists at the time, says Todd, were inclined to speak out against Clinton but didn’t do so because they wanted a seat at the table. (Except for us pro-life feminists, of course, but we weren’t getting any such seat.) My recollection entails much more than that: they thought having Clinton was crucial to keeping abortion readily available, and went to great lengths to support him accordingly. And said so, over and over.

But Clinton stayed in office. Todd thinks this made some evangelical leaders more transactional, as opposed to insisting that character mattered. If people looked the other way with Bill Clinton, maybe people will look the other way with Trump, if he can get them what they want. That was the rationale – flip the switch. Todd explicitly cites the overturning of Roe v. Wade as one of the transactions hoped for.

But Did the Clinton Transaction Work?

Suppose the feminists of the Clinton era had followed their own principles about how young women employees should be treated by the powerful and that they were more concerned about having only people of character being in positions of power. Had Clinton not had the support and been removed from office, what would have happened? While much is difficult to predict, this much we know: Vice President Al Gore would have become President.

Gore was one of those Democrats who had been pro-life early on, but had changed by this time. They would have still had their advocate in office.

We can’t predict for certain but can easily guess that, since he would have been the incumbent, and since in reality he came excruciatingly close to winning the next election without being the incumbent, he could well have won instead of Bush in 2020.

The trajectory of history would be entirely different. And the chances are good that Republicans would have remained as skittish about actually doing anything pro-life on abortion as they were then and have been ever since. The pro-abortion position could possibly be stronger now under this alternative scenario.

We don’t know the future from here on out, but we’re living in the future from that time. People who thought they were being pragmatic and realistic for their own position may well not have been in the long run.

Will the Trump Transaction Work Now?

We did get Roe v. Wade overturned. But the context was not helpful to persuasion. Pro-abortion states have doubled down. The technology of chemical abortions is making the actual numbers of abortions go up after they had been declining for years. I collected together a bunch of conservative commentators expounding:

Trump Sabotaging the Pro-Life Movement

There are in this country millions of people who think Trump is despicable but who admire Pope Leo XIV. A transactional approach that includes corruption is going to alienate a lot of people. Many will appreciate people who stand on principle even if they disagree with the principle itself. That makes them more likely to listen.

I’m still delighted that Roe v. Wade was overturned, of course. But I also knew at the time that it was just a step. The headline I put into our e-newsletter, Peace & Life Connections, was “Major Obstacle Removed.” And it’s a huge relief to have that obstacle removed.

The obstacle of transactional politicians who mainly give lip service to pro-life principles, who don’t take action even just on abortion, much less other life issues, and who taint it all with their own intense corruption and cruel policies – they’re another major obstacle that we have yet to remove.

Removing them at the ballot box would be ideal, but short of that and in the meantime, we need to show cruelty and hypocrisy and violating principles for the intense damage they are. They damage both directly and by hurting the social movements who don’t merely give lip service but really mean it.

Playing political games is something both camps can do. Which one is up and which one is down will vary across time. Only standing on principle remains constant.

FGC Gathering

Rachel MacNair standing on principle at a Quaker gathering.

====================================================================

Because consistent-life candidates are few and mainly for lower offices, our electoral work focuses on referendums, where how to vote is more clear-cut. See our project website:

Peace and Life Referendums: Voting against Violence

 

Get our SHORT Biweekly e-Newsletter



Email & Social Media Marketing by VerticalResponse

elections • politics


One Catholic Case Against Nuclear Deterrence

Posted on September 22, 2026 By

compiled by Fr. Jim Hewes

 

By the end of 1945, the blast, heat, and radiation of the nuclear attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki had killed an estimated 74,000 human beings made in the image of God in Nagasaki and 140,000 human beings made in the image of God in Hiroshima. Most were civilians. Many of those who survived the nuclear attacks would die from radiation-induced illnesses in the years to come. Many historians and other ethical authors now largely agree that the US did not need to drop the bombs to avoid an invasion of Japan and bring an end to World War II.

Today, 9 countries still possess more than 13,000 nuclear weapons. The risk of nuclear war is still with us. To reduce this danger, we must freeze and reverse the arms race and, ultimately, eliminate nuclear weapons. We too easily think that nuclear deterrence works when, in fact, the only entity that benefits is the military-industrial complex with its defense contractors.

Deterrence theory is based upon the concept of the use of threats by one party to convince another party to refrain from initiating some course of action. In 1966, the Second Vatican Council concluded: “Any act of war aimed indiscriminately at the destruction of entire cities or of extensive areas along with their populations is a crime against God and man itself. It merits unequivocal and unhesitating condemnation.” In a pastoral letter in 1983, the US Catholic bishops added: “This condemnation, in our judgment, applies even to the retaliatory use of weapons striking enemy cities after our own have already been struck.” They continued that, “if something is immoral to do, then it is also immoral to threaten.”

Even if one holds to a Just War Theory, if there ever were to be a just war, all the conditions for the just war would have to be completely and strictly upheld. One of the conditions of Just War Theory is that the lives of innocent civilians are never to be taken directly, regardless of the reason for doing so. If one targeted non-combatants for any reason, the war would be unjust. A nuclear war would be only indiscriminate destruction, with the overwhelming killing of mainly civilians.

As Fr. Charlie McCarthy states (and verified in a personal communication to me):

Since Christian Just War Theory cannot be found in Jesus’ teachings, the question is, why didn’t Jesus include a just war theory or even a justified violence teaching as part of His Way? Did He not know about war and violence and their various justifications? Did He just forget for three years to add that to His teaching?  There is no appearance of the Just War Theory in all of the New Testament.  In fact, this theory does not appear in Christianity until over 300 years after Christ.  Christians in that early era of the church, who were closest to Christ, did not participate in war because they saw it as incompatible with Christ’s life and His teaching.

The Just War Theory is not a dogma of the Church. St. Augustine (after St. Ambrose) in developing the Just War tradition, never said there could be a just war. Rather, he stated if Christians were ever to participate in a war, these standards would have to be strictly and completely followed.  The strong moral presumption was always against war and in favor of peace.  It is quite the opposite of what our sad history has shown.

In the “Gospel of Life” Pope John Paul II states: “Life, especially human life, belongs only to God: for this reason, whoever attacks human life in some way attacks God Himself.” If done by launching a nuclear weapon, this would be on a catastrophic scale. Pope John Paul II stated that any war is a failure of humanity. In the case of a nuclear war, the final failure for humanity.

Pope Benedict XVI (2009 World Day of Peace Message, no. 13) stated, “In a nuclear war there would be no victors, only victims. The truth of peace requires that all — whether those governments which openly or secretly possess nuclear arms, or those planning to acquire them— agree to change their course by clear and firm decisions and strive for a progressive and concerted nuclear disarmament. The resources which would be saved could then be employed in projects of development capable of benefiting all their people, especially the poor.”

Pope Francis declared on January 1, 2017 (Fiftieth World Day of Peace) that to be true followers of Jesus includes “making active non-violence our way of life… May charity and non-violence govern how we treat each other as individuals, within society and in the international life… may non-violence be the hallmark of our decisions, our relationships, and our actions and indeed of the political life in all its forms.”

In December 2017, Pope Francis firmly condemned the possession of nuclear weapons for the first time at a Vatican conference on disarmament. The Pope went on to say that if we also take into account the risk of accidental detonation because of error of any kind, and the heightened danger from the threat of their use, their very possession is to be firmly condemned.  Pope Francis also noted both the humanitarian consequences of nuclear weapons use and the “false sense of security” created by nuclear weapons as reasons for condemning possession, as well as the high cost of maintaining a nuclear arsenal.

The International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN) is a broad, inclusive campaign, focused on mobilizing civil society around the world to support the specific objective of prohibiting and eliminating nuclear weapons. To join in the work to end nuclear weapons, go to: https://www.icanw.org/

It took 50 years for an estimated 2.5 billion pre-born children to be killed by abortions world-wide. If there was a nuclear war, there could be 7.8 billion people dead (or wish they were dead) in a day or two. As Martin Luther King, Jr. stated: “The choice is no longer between violence and non-violence, but between nonviolence or nonexistence.”

So, please continue to pray for not only a reduction of nuclear weapons but ultimately that all of them be abolished from the face of the earth. Especially in Russia and the U.S., which together hold 90% of the nuclear weapons in the world.

=============================

For some more of our many posts from Jim Hewes, see: 

Reaching the Chaplain that Blessed the Bomb

A Personal Reflection on a Just War

Exposing Injustice Through Graphic Images

Death Penalty and other Killing: The Destructive Effect on Us

Reflections from My Decades of Consistent Life Experience

Consistent Life History: Being Across the Board

 

 

Get our SHORT Biweekly e-Newsletter



Email & Social Media Marketing by VerticalResponse

Uncategorized


Reaching the Chaplain that Blessed the Bomb

Posted on August 25, 2026 By

by Jim Hewes

 

Fr. Charlie McCarthy [Emanuel Charles McCarthy] once told me about a conference he was to give to the priests of the Diocese of Detroit. The Cardinal sent a letter asking all of his 800 priests to come to Charlie’s presentation. When he got there, only 8 had come. Yet Charlie gave his talks on nonviolence as if there were 800 in attendance.

At each of his talks, one particular priest gave Charlie a hard time, arguing that some violence was justified. Charlie was patient and gentle but also clearly and strongly answered each of his questions.

A few weeks after the conference, Charlie got a surprise call from this very same priest. He wanted Charlie to give those presentations on nonviolence in his own parish. Charlie was taken back by the request, but agreed to come to this priest’s parish. When he gave the presentations, this priest still kept commenting and asking many tough questions of Charlie, but he was not as confrontative as the last time.

A year later Charlie was coming to another parish in Detroit. This same priest heard about it and asked if they could have lunch together. Charlie said that he wouldn’t have the time but why doesn’t he come to lunch at this other parish, where Charlie was presenting; so the priest did come.

During lunch they discussed the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Someone would make a comment about this and this same priest would intervene and comment that the statement that the other person made was not true. A different person made another comment about Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and the priest would intervene again and comment that the statement that this other person made was also not true.

This went on for a while. Finally one person got so upset that he confronted the priest by asking him: “why are you so sure of this? Were you there?”

The priest answered him: “Yes, I was there. I was the Catholic Chaplain that blessed the Christian men who dropped the atom bombs.”

There was silence in the room.

His name was Father George Zabelka. He spent the rest of his life going across the United States and talking on nonviolence. His story can be found at the website: www.centerforchristiannonviolence.org.

There is a meaning for me is his story. Even though it’s so natural to look for numbers in our programs, God has a different purpose. Charlie could have cancelled because there were only 8 people, but that didn’t faze him. As it turned out, one of those eight was Fr. George Zabelka. That was not only an incredible grace of conversion for him, but a tremendous means of grace though his witness to so many people, people that Fr. George touched by his speaking out across the country.

Father George Zabelka, left, with Father Emmanuel Charles McCarthy in Toronto, Aug. 9, 1985 Credit: Photo courtesy of Emmanuel Charles McCarthy, in America: The Jesuit Review

More on Fr. McCarthy

Fr. Charlie McCarthy I consider a friend. Rev. Emmanuel Charles McCarthy is a priest of the Eastern Rite (Byzantine) of the Catholic Church. He was formerly a lawyer, university educator and founder and original director of The Program for the Study and Practice of Nonviolent Conflict Resolution at the University of Notre Dame. He is also a co-founder of Pax Christi-USA.

For over forty years he has directed educational programs and conducted spiritual retreats throughout the world on the issue of the relationship of faith and violence. He is author of three books: All Things Flee Thee for Thou Fleest Me!: A Cry to the Churches and Their Leaders to Stop Running from the Nonviolent Jesus and His Nonviolent Way, August 9, and Christian Just War Theory: The Logic of Deceit. He has also authored numerous essays and articles on the subject of violence and religion.

His audio/video series on Gospel Nonviolence, Behold the Lamb, is internationally recognized as the most spiritually penetrating and logically ordered presentation on this dimension of the person and teaching of Jesus available in this format. Emmanuel Charles McCarthy was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize for his life’s work on behalf of peace within people and among people.

These quotes come from Abortion and War, October 4, 2011, though the full article is no longer up – but there is a video version:

As I read the triumphant headlines in the newspapers day after day—‘U.S. Pounds Iraq from Air’—and saw the pictures of missiles streaking into Iraq, I could not help but hear the silent screams of all the little Iraqi children in utero who were having their lives ripped from them. The lucky ones were the ones who took a direct hit. The ones, who were aborted because of percussion, vibration or because of the terror, trauma, malnourishment and/or exhaustion visited upon their mothers by war, would probably have suffered less agonizing deaths at the wrong end of a suction machine in an abortion clinic     . . .

In the very first news program I saw on TV after the start of the 1991 war between the U.S. and Iraq, an American pilot was being interviewed. He said he experienced no interference in dropping his bombs and that when he left Baghdad, “It was lit up like a Christmas tree!” . . .  To analogize a Baghdad of a thousand horror-filled infernos to a “lit Christmas tree” is a grotesque misrepresentation of the event that is taking place.  However, it is an accurate representation of a human mind and heart drugged into a moral stupor by the war propaganda of erotic nationalism. . . .  Is it not the flagrant misnaming of reality that is the foundation for all pro-abortion philosophies and politics? Is it not the obstinate refusal to call murder by its correct name, murder, that is at the heart of the pro-choice position? Is not the misnaming of murder as just another “medical operation” the hook on which all pro-choice propaganda hangs?”

=========================

For more of our posts relating to the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, here are two recent ones:

Get our SHORT Biweekly e-Newsletter



Email & Social Media Marketing by VerticalResponse

nuclear weapons